SENATE OF VIRGINIA                                          MINUTE BOOK



                            Thursday, March 7, 1996

Called to order at 10:00 a.m. by Lt. Governor, Donald S. Beyer, Jr.

Prayer offered by The Rev. Ronald N. Boswell, Pastor
  Grove Avenue Baptist Church, Richmond, Virginia.

ROLL CALL OF MEMBERS - Quorum Present.

Motion of Senator Whipple dispensed with Reading of Journal (39-Y 0-N).

COMMUNICATION FROM HOUSE (HN10306):  (Reading waived 38-Y 0-N).
Senate Bills with House Amendments Passed:  SB 26, 52, 208, 219, 222, 448,
  481, 484, 627.
Senate Bills with House Substitutes Passed:  SB 44, 136, 147, 306, 362, 485,
  535, 607.
Senate Bills with House Substitutes with Amendments Passed:  SB 347, 587.
House Insisted on its Substitute and Requested Committee of Conference:
  SB 541.
Senate Bill with Conference Report Concurred In:  SB 12.
House Bills with Senate Amendments Rejected:  HB 148, 305.
House Bills with Senate Substitutes Rejected:  HB 987, 1524.
House Bills with Conference Reports Concurred In:  HB 36, 462, 631.
House Bill Amended in Accordance with Recommendation of Governor:  HB 1485.
Senate Joint Resolution with House Amendments Agreed To:  SJR 61.
Senate Joint Resolutions with House Substitutes Agreed To:  SJR 92, 110.
Senate Joint Resolution with House Substitute with Amendments Agreed To:
  SJR 128.
House Joint Resolution Agreed To:  HJR 357.
Senate Bills Passed:  SB 18, 22, 46, 78, 141, 144, 162, 164, 198, 218, 223,
  334, 360, 405, 427.
House Bills with Senate Amendments Concurred In:  HB 106, 619, 695, 772, 796,
  825, 892, 925, 986, 1307, 1355, 1372.
House Bills with Senate Substitutes Concurred In:  HB 44, 566, 807.
House Bill with Senate Substitute with Amendment Concurred In:  HB 1329.
Senate Joint Resolution Agreed To:  SJR 73.
House Joint Resolution with Senate Amendments Agreed To:  HJR 240.

House Joint Resolution Laid on Clerk's Desk:  See March 8 Senate Calendar.
Senate Bills and Joint Resolutions with House Amendments, Substitutes and
  Substitutes with Amendments Placed on Calendar.

Rules suspended, privilege of the floor given to distinguished visitors
  (38-Y 0-N).

CALENDAR

BILLS IN CONFERENCE
H.B. 36, Conference Report concurred in (35-Y 0-N).
H.B. 631, Conference Report concurred in (38-Y 0-N).
S.B. 575, Conference Report concurred in (38-Y 0-N).

UNFINISHED BUSINESS - HOUSE
H.B. 14, Senate insisted on its substitute and requested Committee of
  Conference (39-Y 0-N).
H.B. 265, Senate insisted on its amendments and requested Committee of
  Conference (40-Y 0-N).  House informed.
H.B. 464, Senate insisted on its amendments and requested Committee of
  Conference (40-Y 0-N).
H.B. 618, Senate insisted on its substitute and requested Committee of
  Conference (38-Y 1-N).
H.B. 748, Senate insisted on its amendment and requested Committee of
  Conference (40-Y 0-N).
H.B. 1062, Senate insisted on its amendment and requested Committee of
  Conference (40-Y 0-N).
H.B. 1077, Senate insisted on its amendment and requested Committee of
  Conference (40-Y 0-N).
H.B. 1163, Senate insisted on its substitute and requested Committee of
  Conference (40-Y 0-N).
H.B. 1195, Senate insisted on its amendments and requested Committee of
  Conference (40-Y 0-N).
H.J.R. 222, Senate insisted on its substitute with amendments and requested
 Committee of Conference (voice vote).

UNFINISHED BUSINESS - SENATE
S.B. 249, Senate acceded to House request for Committee of Conference
  (38-Y 0-N).
S.B. 541, Senate acceded to House request for Committee of Conference
  (39-Y 0-N), conferees appointed:  Senators Saslaw, Barry and Whipple.
S.B. 28, House amendments concurred in (39-Y 0-N).
S.B. 35, House amendments concurred in (39-Y 0-N).
S.B. 38, House amendment concurred in (37-Y 0-N).
S.B. 236, House amendment concurred in (38-Y 0-N).
S.B. 251, House amendment concurred in (39-Y 0-N).
S.B. 262, House amendment concurred in (40-Y 0-N).
S.B. 300, House amendments concurred in (39-Y 0-N).
S.B. 302, House amendments concurred in (39-Y 0-N).
S.B. 343, House substitute concurred in (38-Y 1-N).
S.B. 384, House substitute concurred in (40-Y 0-N).
S.B. 428, House amendments concurred in (39-Y 0-N).
S.B. 433, House substitute rejected (7-Y 31-N).
S.B. 497, House substitute concurred in (37-Y 2-N).
S.B. 534, House substitute concurred in (40-Y 0-N).
S.B. 536, House amendment concurred in (39-Y 0-N).
S.B. 543, House amendments concurred in (39-Y 0-N).
S.B. 565, House substitute rejected (2-Y 36-N).
S.B. 580, House substitute with amendments rejected (1-Y 39-N).
S.B. 594, House amendments rejected (2-Y 38-N).

S.J.R. 171 and 172 offered by Senator Edwards (consent to introduce
  38-Y 0-N).
S.J.R. 173 offered by Senator Ticer (consent to introduce 38-Y 0-N).

Joint Resolutions laid on Clerk's Desk under Senate Rule 26(g) and HJR 2:
  See March 8 Senate Calendar.

SENATE BILLS WITH GOVERNOR'S AMENDMENTS
S.B. 273, Governor's amendments concurred in (40-Y 0-N).
S.B. 330, Governor's substitute concurred in (40-Y 0-N).

UNCONTESTED CALENDAR
HOUSE BILLS ON THIRD READING
Read third time.
H.B. 785S, Earley floor substitute offered, Chair ruled substitute not
  germane, ruling of Chair appealed, ruling of Chair not sustained
  (19-Y 20-N), Earley floor substitute agreed to (23-Y 16-N), Woods floor
  amendments rejected (17-Y 21-N), Couric amendment rejected (18-Y 21-N),
  Whipple floor amendment rejected (15-Y 23-N), reconsideration of Whipple
  floor amendment agreed to (40-Y 0-N), Whipple floor amendment rejected
  (17-Y 23-N), Ticer floor amendment rejected (19-Y 21-N), Lucas floor
  amendment rejected (18-Y 22-N), engrossed, passed (25-Y 15-N).
H.B. 1199SA, Engrossed, passed (40-Y 0-N).
H.B. 1411SA, Holland floor amendment agreed to, engrossed, passed (40-Y 0-N).
  House informed.

S.J.R. 174 offered by Senator Lucas (consent to introduce 38-Y 0-N).
S.R. 13 offered by Senator Houck (consent to introduce 39-Y 0-N).

Resolutions laid on Clerk's Desk under Senate Rule 26(g) and HJR 2:  See
  March 8 Senate Calendar.

On motion of Senator Saslaw, the Senate recessed at 12:20 p.m. to reconvene
  at 1:35 p.m.

The Senate reconvened at 1:35 p.m.

CALENDAR (continued)

REGULAR CALENDAR
HOUSE BILLS ON THIRD READING
Read third time.
H.B. 214S, Edwards floor amendment rejected (17-Y 23-N), engrossed, passed
  (26-Y 13-N).  House informed.
H.B. 1128A, Stolle floor amendment agreed to, engrossed, failed to pass
  (13-Y 27-N).
H.B. 1300S, Engrossed, pending question ordered (25-Y 14-N), passed
  (32-Y 8-N).  House informed.

RESOLUTIONS REPORTED ON THIRD READING
Read third time.
H.J.R. 160SA, Waddell floor amendments agreed to, engrossed, agreed to
  (voice vote).  House informed.
H.J.R. 36, Rejected (voice vote).
H.J.R. 185A, Motion to recommit to Rules agreed to.

MEMORIAL RESOLUTIONS
Taken up and agreed to.
H.J.R. 342
H.J.R. 344
H.J.R. 345
H.J.R. 346
S.J.R. 158
S.J.R. 160
S.J.R. 163
S.J.R. 166
S.J.R. 170
S.R. 10

COMMENDING RESOLUTIONS
Taken up and agreed to (voice vote).
H.J.R. 341
H.J.R. 347
H.J.R. 348
H.J.R. 349
H.J.R. 350
H.J.R. 352
H.J.R. 353
S.J.R. 162
S.J.R. 164
S.J.R. 165
S.J.R. 167
S.J.R. 168
S.J.R. 169
S.R. 12

COMMUNICATION FROM HOUSE (HN10307):  (Reading waived 38-Y 0-N).
Senate Bill with House Substitute with Amendments Concurred In:  SB 113.
House Insisted on its Substitute and Requested Committee of Conference:
  SB 507.
House Insisted on its Substitute with Amendment and Requested Committee
  of Conference:  SB 170.
House Acceded to Senate Request for Committees of Conference:  HB 31, 470,
  488, 800.
House Acceded to Senate Request for Committees of Conference:  HJR 104, 221.
COMMUNICATION FROM HOUSE (HN20307):  (Reading waived 38-Y 0-N).
Senate Bill with House Amendments Passed:  SB 460.
House Bills Passed:  HB 1554, 1555.
House Joint Resolutions Agreed To:  HJR 336, 337, 338, 351.
Senate Bill Passed:  SB 464.

House Bills Referred and House Joint Resolutions Laid on Clerk's Desk:
  See March 8 Senate Calendar.
Senate Bills with House Amendments and Substitute with Amendments
  Placed on Calendar.

SUPPLEMENTAL CALENDAR NO. 1

UNFINISHED BUSINESS - HOUSE
H.B. 148, Senate insisted on its amendments and requested Committee of
  Conference (40-Y 0-N).
H.B. 305, Senate insisted on its amendment and requested Committee of
  Conference (40-Y 0-N).
H.B. 987, Senate insisted on its substitute and requested Committee of
  Conference (40-Y 0-N).
H.B. 1524, Senate insisted on its substitute and requested Committee of
  Conference (40-Y 0-N).

UNFINISHED BUSINESS - SENATE
S.B. 26, House amendments 1-5 concurred in (38-Y 0-N), House amendment 6
  concurred in (38-Y 0-N).
S.B. 44, House substitute rejected (8-Y 31-N).
S.B. 52, House amendments concurred in (40-Y 0-N).
S.B. 136, House substitute concurred in (39-Y 1-N).
S.B. 147, House substitute concurred in (40-Y 0-N).
S.B. 208, House amendment concurred in (39-Y 0-N).
S.B. 219, House amendments concurred in (39-Y 1-N).
S.B. 222, House amendment concurred in (40-Y 0-N).
S.B. 306, House substitute rejected (2-Y 38-N).
S.B. 347, House substitute with amendments rejected (1-Y 39-N).
S.B. 362, House substitute concurred in (40-Y 0-N).
S.B. 448, House amendments rejected (0-Y 40-N).
S.B. 481, House amendments concurred in (40-Y 0-N).
S.B. 484, House amendments concurred in (40-Y 0-N).
S.B. 485, House substitute concurred in (40-Y 0-N).
S.B. 535, House substitute concurred in (38-Y 0-N).
S.B. 587, House substitute with amendments concurred in (37-Y 2-N),
  reconsideration agreed to (40-Y 0-N), concurred in (32-Y 7-N).
S.B. 607, House substitute rejected (1-Y 38-N).
S.B. 627, House amendment concurred in (36-Y 1-N).
S.J.R. 61, House amendments 1-4 concurred in (voice vote), House amendment 5
  rejected (voice vote).
S.J.R. 92, House substitute concurred in (voice vote).
S.J.R. 110, House substitute concurred in (voice vote).
S.J.R. 128, House substitute with amendments concurred in (voice vote).

SUPPLEMENTAL CALENDAR NO. 2

UNFINISHED BUSINESS - SENATE
S.B. 170, Senate acceded to House request for Committee of Conference
  (40-Y 0-N).
S.B. 507, Senate acceded to House request for Committee of Conference
  (40-Y 0-N).
S.B. 113, House substitute with amendments concurred in (38-Y 0-N).
S.B. 460, House amendments concurred in (39-Y 0-N).

On motion of Senator Saslaw, the Senate recessed at 3:10 p.m. to reconvene
  at 5:10 p.m.

The Senate reconvened at 5:10 p.m.

COMMUNICATION FROM HOUSE (HN30307):  (Reading waived 37-Y 1-N).
House Insisted on its Amendments and Requested Committee of Conference:
  SB 594.
House Insisted on its Substitute and Requested Committee of Conference:
  SB 433, 565.
House Insisted on its Substitute with Amendments and Requested Committee
  of Conference:  SB 580.
Senate Bill with Conference Report Concurred In:  SB 623.
Senate Bill with Conference Report Rejected and Requested Second Committee
  of Conference:  SB 575.
House Bills with Senate Amendments Rejected:  HB 520, 1495.
House Bills with Senate Substitutes Rejected:  HB 251, 616, 928.
House Bill with Senate Substitute with Amendments Rejected:  HB 293.
House Acceded to Senate Request for Committees of Conference:  HB 14, 464,
  618, 748, 1062, 1077, 1163, 1195.
House Bills with Conference Reports Concurred In:  HB 1212, 1350, 1490.
House Bills Amended in Accordance with Recommendation of Governor:  HB 507,
  644, 812, 1052.
House Joint Resolutions Agreed To:  HJR 354, 355, 356, 358, 359, 360, 361.
House Acceded to Senate Request for Committee of Conference:  HJR 222.

House Joint Resolutions Laid on Clerk's Desk:  See March 8 Senate Calendar.

SUPPLEMENTAL CALENDAR NO. 3

UNFINISHED BUSINESS - HOUSE
H.B. 251, Senate insisted on its substitute and requested Committee of
  Conference (37-Y 0-N).
H.B. 293, Senate insisted on its substitute with amendments and requested
  Committee of Conference (37-Y 1-N).
H.B. 520, Senate insisted on its amendment and requested Committee of
  Conference (39-Y 0-N).
H.B. 616, Senate insisted on its substitute and requested Committee of
  Conference (38-Y 0-N).
H.B. 928, Senate insisted on its substitute and requested Committee of
  Conference (39-Y 0-N).
H.B. 1495, Senate insisted on its amendment and requested Committee of
  Conference (38-Y 0-N).

UNFINISHED BUSINESS - SENATE
S.B. 433, Senate acceded to House request for Committee of Conference
  (39-Y 0-N).
S.B. 565, Senate acceded to House request for Committee of Conference
  (40-Y 0-N).
S.B. 580, Senate acceded to House request for Committee of Conference
  (40-Y 0-N).
S.B. 594, Senate acceded to House request for Committee of Conference
  (40-Y 0-N).

CONFEREES APPOINTED
H.B 14, Senators Stosch, Lambert and Potts.
H.B. 31, Senators Holland, Wampler and Stosch.
H.B. 464, Senators Edwards, Stosch and Potts.
H.B. 470, Senators Earley, Williams and Goode.
H.B. 488, Senators Benedetti, Reasor and Goode.
H.B. 800, Senators Hawkins, Potts and Reasor.
H.B. 1195, Senators Woods, Howell and Trumbo.
H.J.R. 104, Senators Marye, Wampler and Houck.
H.J.R. 221, Senators Holland, Reasor and Wampler.
H.J.R. 222, Senators Goode, Houck and Barry.
S.B. 170, Senators K.G. Miller, Hanger and Whipple.
S.B. 249, Senators Holland, Wampler and Stosch.

On motion of Senator Saslaw, the Senate recessed at 5:25 p.m. to reconvene
  at 6:45 p.m.

The Senate reconvened at 6:45 p.m.

COMMUNICATION FROM HOUSE (HN40307):  (Reading waived 37-Y 2-N).
Senate Bills Amended in Accordance with Recommendation of Governor:  SB 56,
  143, 480.
House Bills with Senate Amendments Concurred In:  HB 65, 453, 563, 722, 1093,
  1141, 1418, 1440, 1521.
House Bills with Senate Substitutes Concurred In:  HB 837, 877,1068, 1284.
House Bills with Senate Substitutes with Amendments Concurred In:  HB 769,
  1069.
COMMUNICATION FROM HOUSE (HN50307):  (Reading waived 37-Y 2-N).
House Insisted on its Amendments and Requested Committee of Conference:
  SB 448.
House Insisted on its Substitute and Requested Committees of Conference:
  SB 44, 306, 607.
House Insisted on its Substitute with Amendments and Requested Committee
  of Conference:  SB 347.
House Acceded to Senate Request for Committees of Conference:  HB 148, 265,
  305, 987, 1524.
House Insisted on its Amendment and Requested Committee of Conference:
  SJR 61.

S.J.R. 175 offered by Senator Waddell (consent to introduce 37-Y 2-N).

Joint Resolution laid on Clerk's Desk under Senate Rule 26(g) and HJR 2:
  See March 8 Senate Calendar.

CONFEREES APPOINTED
H.B. 148, Senators Lucas, Williams and Marsh.
H.B. 265, Senators Marsh, Reasor and Edwards.
H.B. 305, Senators K.G. Miller, Marye and Benedetti.
H.B. 987, Senators Quayle, Newman and Lambert.
H.B. 1524, Senators Lambert, Benedetti and Stosch.
S.B. 433, Senators Stolle, Marsh and Lucas.
S.B. 507, Senators Lambert, Hanger and Newman.
S.B. 565, Senators Earley, Williams and Goode.
S.B. 594, Senators Norment, Lambert and Houck.

MESSAGE FROM HOUSE:  Speaker ruled Senate substitute not germane on HB 785.

On motion of Senator Saslaw, the Senate recessed at 6:50 p.m. to reconvene
  at 8:45 p.m.

The Senate reconvened at 8:45 p.m.

COMMUNICATION FROM HOUSE (HN60307):  (Reading waived 38-Y 0-N).
House Bill with Senate Amendments Rejected:  HB 1071.
House Bills with Senate Substitutes Rejected:  HB 286, 292.
House Bill with Senate Substitute with Amendments Rejected:  HB 123.
House Joint Resolution with Senate Substitute Rejected:  HJR 125.
House Joint Resolution with Senate Substitute with Amendments Rejected:
  HJR 196.
COMMUNICATION FROM HOUSE (HN70307):  (Reading waived 38-Y 0-N).
Senate Bill with House Substitute Passed:  SB 637.
House Acceded to Senate Request for Committees of Conference:  HB 251, 293,
  520, 616, 928, 1495.

Senate Bill with House Substitute Placed on Calendar.

SUPPLEMENTAL CALENDAR NO. 4

UNFINISHED BUSINESS - SENATE
S.B. 44, Senate acceded to House request for Committee of Conference
  (36-Y 0-N).
S.B. 306, Senate acceded to House request for Committee of Conference
  (36-Y 0-N).
S.B. 347, Senate acceded to House request for Committee of Conference
  (37-Y 0-N).
S.B. 448, Senate acceded to House request for Committee of Conference
  (37-Y 0-N).
S.B. 607, Senate acceded to House request for Committee of Conference
  (39-Y 0-N).
S.J.R. 61, Senate acceded to House request for Committee of Conference
  (voice vote).

SUPPLEMENTAL CALENDAR NO. 5

UNFINISHED BUSINESS - HOUSE
H.B. 123, Senate insisted on its substitute with amendments and requested
  Committee of Conference (39-Y 0-N).
H.B. 286, Senate insisted on its substitute and requested Committee of
  Conference (40-Y 0-N).
H.B. 292, Senate insisted on its substitute and requested Committee of
  Conference (40-Y 0-N).
H.B. 1071, Senate insisted on its amendments and requested Committee of
  Conference (40-Y 0-N).
H.J.R. 125, Senate insisted on its substitute and requested Committee of
  Conference (voice vote).
H.J.R. 196, Senate insisted on its substitute with amendments and requested
  Committee of Conference (voice vote).

CONFEREES APPOINTED
H.B. 251, Senators Reasor, Lucas and Earley.
H.B. 618, Senators Lucas, Saslaw and Trumbo.
H.B. 748, Senators Benedetti, Lambert and Martin.
H.B. 1062, Senators Marye, Hawkins and Bolling.
H.B. 1077, Senators Marsh, Saslaw and Edwards.
H.B. 1163, Senators Ticer, Barry and Waddell.
S.B. 448, Senators Stosch, Holland and Hanger.

UNFINISHED BUSINESS - HOUSE
H.B. 365, House amendments concurred in (39-Y 0-N).  House informed.

CONFEREES APPOINTED
H.B. 123, Senators Chichester, Martin and Edwards.
H.B. 286, Senators Marsh, Edwards and Lucas.
H.B. 292, Senators Marye, Barry and Hawkins.
H.B. 293, Senators Stosch, Holland and Barry.
H.B. 520, Senators Houck, Waddell and Williams.
H.B. 616, Senators Lucas, Howell and Reasor.
H.B. 928, Senators Howell, Reasor and Edwards.
H.B. 1071, Senators Woods, Goode and Couric.
H.B. 1495, Senators Ticer, Barry and Saslaw.
H.J.R. 125, Senators Lambert, Woods and Couric.
H.J.R. 196, Senators Holland, Houck and Barry.
S.B. 44, Senators Reasor, Lucas and Earley.
S.B. 306, Senators Holland, Stosch and Wampler.
S.B. 347, Senators Wampler, Waddell and K.G. Miller.
S.B. 580, Senators Ticer, Waddell and Reasor.
S.B. 607, Senators Lambert, Benedetti and Houck.
S.J.R. 61, Senators Benedetti, Marsh and Houck.

COMMUNICATION FROM HOUSE (HN80307):
House Bills with Senate Amendments Concurred In:  HB 901, 1007, 1008, 1076,
  1328, 1438, 1512.
House Bills with Senate Substitutes Concurred In:  HB 222, 997, 1123, 1300,
  1384.
House Bills with Senate Substitutes with Amendments Concurred In:  HB 1199,
  1411, 1466.
Senate Joint Resolutions Agreed To:  SJR 146, 159.
House Joint Resolutions with Senate Amendments Agreed To:  HJR 7, 13, 16, 52,
  64, 65, 82, 135, 152, 159, 168, 171, 179, 180, 183, 187, 216, 227, 228,
  244.
House Joint Resolutions with Senate Substitutes Agreed To:  HJR 87, 194,
  205, 206, 243, 252.
House Joint Resolution with Senate Substitute with Amendments Agreed To:
  HJR 160.

On motion of Senator Holland, the Senate adjourned at 9:30 p.m.
  to convene Friday, March 8 at 10:00 a.m.




Key:  A = Amendment(s);  S = Substitute;  SA = Substitute with Amendment(s)

Legislative Information System